1. The definitions of argument, debate, dispute and quarrel differ in several ways. I found that in the definition of quarrel it included the word "angry" which was not included in the other definitions. This means to me that is is an emotional disagreement. In looking up debate, it differed by explaining that it is a formal discussion or argument. It is something planned out, scheduled and prepared for. An argument is showing or demonstrating a truth or falsehood. This could be used in researching something to show how it could be false. The dictionary mentioned the word argument as a proof of evidence. Dispute was stated as something to argue about or question the truth or validity. So to me, it would be something to use if you have questions about the statements presented and wanted to research further. The differences I found seem to be in the way that you presented your disagreement, whether it was emotionally, formally, researched or questioned.
They overlap by using some of the same wording to define the different words. They are basically the same concept that they all are disagreements that are presented in different ways.
2. I haven't had much experience with debate. I have only watched political debates. I don't participate in any debates but do enjoy watching them. I feel as though they are very important and educational. I like that they are in a controlled environment and even timed.
I have had plenty of experience with arguments. My children have presented me with their argument, that they can still do good in school without the proper amount of sleep. I would argue that they cannot. Which I will demonstrate to them when the report cards come home.
I also have had experience with disputing. For example, I dispute the fact that my daughter came home before 1:00am last week. I question the validity of that information and will have a verbal discussion with her.
Now we come to the word quarrel. I have used this in my life more than I care to admit. I have a lot of experiences to choose from. I have and will quarrel with my husband to get my side of the issue understood. My emotions seem to get involved to some degree, mostly because I am discussing the issues when I am already upset.
No comments:
Post a Comment